Decoding the Water Softening Conundrum: A Comprehensive Guide

Mark Alpers
August 31, 2023

Water softening is an art, one often shrouded in mystery, mainly due to the technical jargon and myriad options available. This guide demystifies the concept, the necessity, and the options of water softeners, offering a comprehensive overview catered for the UK audience yet universally applicable.

The Genesis: Understanding "Why"

Before delving into the intricacies of water softeners, it’s essential to decode the ‘why’ – the core reason necessitating this investment. The culprit is hard water, an unassuming yet potent element with an affinity for calcium and magnesium, causing the dreaded limescale.

The Genesis of Hard Water

Ironically, rainwater is naturally soft. It’s as it percolates through the earth absorbing minerals like calcium and magnesium that it becomes “hard”. These minerals, not initially present in rainwater, are introduced through natural processes and can also be absorbed from pipes and faucets.

Hard Water Unearthed

Characterized by high mineral content, stemming from its journey through chalk and limestone terrains, hard water is infamous for its limescale legacy. This unwelcome residue, a whitish deposit, is a common sight on kettles, taps, and sinks.

Diagnosis: Do You Have Hard Water?

A strip test, a swift and reliable method, or a more detailed water test offers clarity on your water’s hardness. Limescale’s persistent presence is another telltale sign of hard water’s reign.

The Invisible Impact

While the visible limescale hints at hard water’s existence, the invisible damage, particularly to appliances and plumbing, is often underestimated. Its insidious nature makes it a silent destroyer, often revealing its devastation when it’s too late.

WATER HARDNESS MAP USA

The video below is one way to check if your water is “hard”. If yes, you might need to consider a way to soften the water. By softening I mean how you avoid and remove mineral build up.

Navigating through the Water Softener Landscape

Understanding the operation of water softeners is pivotal. They revolve around the principle of ion exchange, where hardness minerals are traded for sodium ions, facilitated by resin beads housed in a mineral tank.

Metered or Volume Controlled Softeners

These softeners boast precision, measuring water usage and initiating the regeneration of resin beads based on consumption patterns and water hardness. It’s an intelligent system ensuring optimal performance and efficiency.

Electric/Electronic Softeners

Technology’s touch graces these softeners, with gadgets monitoring water usage and controlling the regeneration cycle, offering a blend of precision and convenience.

Non-Electric Softeners

Driven by water pressure, these softeners are mechanical maestros, monitoring water usage and initiating regeneration as the soft water supply nears depletion.

Time-Controlled Softeners

These are set to regenerate at specific intervals, offering consistency yet potentially leading to wastage or insufficient supply if not calibrated based on actual water usage and hardness.

Single vs Twin Cylinder Softeners

The duel between these two encompasses salt compatibility, continuous soft water supply, and design complexity. Single cylinders are compatible with tablet and granular salts and offer on-demand soft water. In contrast, twin cylinders, often termed block salt softeners, ensure a 24/7 softened water supply but boast a more complex design.

Whole House Water Softener ONLY System

Softener and whole house filter in a single device.
Comes with a digital metered, on demand valve.

Whole House Filter AND Softener System Combination

Softener AND whole house filter in a single device.
Treats 48,000 grains, which is sufficient for very hard water.
Has a capacity that is sufficient for 1-3 bathrooms.
Multi-stage filter including NSF certified carbon filters.

Choosing the Best Water Softener for Your Home

A Special Citrus Treat Awaits!

Embarking on the journey to select the perfect water softener for your abode requires some preparation. This comprehensive guide aims to navigate you through this process, armed with crucial information and key questions that need addressing.

4 Essential Questions to Guide Your Choice

1. Design & Installation:

Contemplate the ideal design ensuring thorough water softening in your home. Consider whether a centralized installation for whole-house softening or a localized solution for specific areas like the kitchen is more suitable.

2. Softening Capacity:

Evaluate the extent of water softening required, influenced by the hardness level of your water and the consumption needs of your household.

3. Regeneration Process:

Estimate the volume of water and salt essential for the regeneration process, crucial for maintaining the softener’s efficacy.

4. Budget:

Balance the initial investment and running costs, focusing on quality and reliability as a long-term asset. Premium softeners often offset their costs with lower maintenance and operational expenses.

Best Brands to Consider

Identifying a brand is often influenced by individual requirements. However, renowned brands include:

Aquasana
Pelican
Fleck
Crystal Quest
Waterboss
EcoWater
Culligan
Kenmore
Whirlpool
Morton

For UK Residents:

Several companies specialize in water softening technologies:

EcoWater
Kinetico
Harvey Water Softeners
TwinTec
Monarch Water
Culligan UK

Cost Implications

The investment in a water softening system varies, influenced by brand, model, capacity, and installation requirements. Domestic units in the US range from $675 to $2,500, excluding installation. Commercial units, designed for larger capacities, oscillate between $1,500 and $12,000+.

Running Costs

Maintenance is inevitable. Non-electrical softeners won’t impact your electricity bills, while electric models may add approximately 75 cents per day. Annual salt costs for a small household hover around $100-$120. Despite these, the savings on bottled water and limescale removers, coupled with enhanced heating efficiency, often justify the expenditure.

DIY Installation Insights

For the adept and adventurous, DIY installation can be a viable option, though professional installation is often recommended for optimal performance and safety. A detailed installation guide can be a valuable resource for DIY enthusiasts.

The Final Verdict

Selecting the perfect water softener is a blend of science and personal preferences. The balance between the initial investment and ongoing operational costs, the capacity to effectively soften water, and the ease of maintenance and operation are pivotal. The ideal unit should not only alleviate hard water woes but also enhance the overall water quality, safeguarding appliances and offering a superior, softer water experience for the entire household.


Treats hard water UP TO 25 ppm (low to medium low hard water).	Treats hard water OVER 25 ppm (medium to extremely hard water).
Does NOT require electricity.	Requires electricity if using the electronic head monitor.
Control Your System With An App:? NO	Control Your System With An App:? YES
- Powerful salt-FREE water softener. - 1,000,000 one million gallon capacity. - Aquasana Rhino exceeds NSF standards. - Treats hard water WITHOUT salt. - Removes chlorine, bacteria, iron, sulfide, manganese, mercury, lead etc. - Includes pre-filter, copper-zinc and carbon filtration stages with standard fittings. - 90-Day Pure Satisfaction Guarantee. - Limited 10 year warranty.	- Powerful salt-BASED water softener. - 1,000,000 one million gallon capacity. - Also includes a multi-stage filter. - Easy installation (inside or outside) - Sufficient for 1-3 bathrooms (options for 4-6 and 7+ bathrooms also available). - 6 month money back guarantee. - Limited lifetime warranty.

City Sewers

Private Sewers & Septic Systems

Treatment Plants