Hey everybody, Welcome to our detailed guide on finding the Best Water Softener For Iron Removal!
I began a comprehensive study to understand the best Water Softeners For Iron Removal.
After investing countless hours into research, testing, and analyzing customer feedback.
From scrutinizing the most minor components to comparing dozens of models side-by-side, my review process was anything but superficial. To bring you the best, I evaluated dozens of water filtration solutions for iron and rust removal.
I looked at their efficiency, durability, and how well they remove iron from water, ensuring you get insights that are both broad in scope and meticulous in detail.
I’ve done the legwork to save you not just money, but also time and the hassle of guesswork. There are lots of solutions on the market, but not every solution is fit for purpose for your needs.
My focus is to ensure you invest in a water filtration solution gives you years of payback.
At the end, my goal is to help you feel reassured knowing that you are serving your family water that is as clear, clean, and safe as it is refreshing. Take pride in a well-maintained home, where appliances operate flawlessly and plumbing systems remain robust, all thanks to the absence of detrimental iron and rust buildup.
1
Best pick for Iron between 8 and 30 PPM
2
Best pick for Iron up to 10 PPM
3
Best pick for Iron between 4 and 7 PPM
4
Best pick for Iron up to 3 PPM
5
Best Pick for High Flow Rates and Commercial Use
The degree of iron in water across the U.S varies significantly however certain soils and rocks are notably rich in iron minerals. This natural occurrence leads to iron dissolution into groundwater as rainfall or snowmelt permeates through these iron-bearing layers.
Additionally, iron contamination can also stem from the corrosion of iron or steel structures within wells or water pipelines, mirroring the process of a metal pail rusting when exposed to moisture and air. This dissolved iron often leaves behind unsightly rust stains on household plumbing and laundry.
While iron presence in water is generally not a health hazard—considering the human body’s need for iron to facilitate oxygen transport in the bloodstream—it primarily garners nutritional iron through food, as waterborne iron is not readily absorbed.
However, the presence of iron in water supplies, especially in wells, warrants attention due to its potential role in fostering the growth of harmful bacteria. Certain bacteria thrive on iron, making it challenging to eradicate them from water sources already rich in this mineral.
Consequently, in areas like Minnesota, where high iron levels are prevalent, monitoring and managing iron levels in water is essential (Minnesota Department of Health, 2023) not only for aesthetic and maintenance reasons but also for ensuring water safety.
It comes in a soluble state, meaning that it’s dissolved and it’s in solution. If you pour a glass of water with dissolved iron, that water is crystal clear. When it oxidizes, it becomes ferric iron. Now it’s a solid. It’s actually a filterable particulate.
The third most common form of iron we see is bacterial iron, and that’s when bacteria bonds with iron in the well and it creates this nasty, slimy stuff that is very hard to get out.
Sometimes the iron can be in both forms. It can be both ferric and ferrous. So, if the water has a tint to it, that means that some of that iron is already out of solution in the ferric form. That’s filterable. We can put a sediment filter and probably capture that, but we also want to know if there’s ferrous iron still in the solution.
And in order to find that out, we have to do a simple test. Iron tests are available either in test strips or in chemical titration-type home tests that you can do yourself. But it’s very important to understand that level of iron. Because if it’s in solution, we have to do something to turn it into a ferric form or capture it in its ferrous state.
We usually send all our test to My Tap Score and the Well Test would be most recommended test to get a holistic application, if you are getting your water supply from a private well. Otherwise they do have test specifically for Metals and Minerals Testing, at half the cost.
Manganese: Commonly accompanies Iron in groundwater, staining laundry and appliances black. Removal methods are similar to those for Iron, discussed later.
Hydrogen Sulfide: Recognizable by its rotten-egg smell, this invisible gas forms from sulfates reacting with magnesium and is eliminated through same filtration process that iron is removed from water (also known as the oxidation process).
Identifying and treating iron in well water is complex, necessitating analysis of iron type (ferric, ferrous, or bacteria), concentration, and pH level, followed by applying specific methods like oxidation, ion exchange, or chemical feed.
While low iron levels (below 3 ppm) can be managed with water softeners alone, higher concentrations demand iron filters. Iron removal strategies vary; softeners exchange ions but falter with ferric iron or high concentrations, while iron filters and chemical methods tackle more severe cases.
Iron levels and water conditions can fluctuate, making continuous monitoring challenging. Consequently, our recommendation is to have an Iron Filter installed as the pre-filter stage before the water hits your water softener.
TOP TIP: Iron in water often coexists with minerals like manganese, calcium, and magnesium. Comprehensive treatment, like water softeners, is essential not only for iron removal but also to address these accompanying substances, ensuring overall water quality and protecting appliances from mineral-induced damage.
1
Best pick for Iron between 8 and 30 PPM
Best for: The SoftPro Iron Master AIO is a system best for those on a medium budget with a primary concern to removes iron, sulfur and manganese, usually occurring from their private well water.
The Flow rate: depends on which filter size you choose:
Certifications:
Pros
Cons
Pop over to the SoftPro Iron Master AIO Well Water Iron Filter product page and scroll to bottom to see some of these reviews.
The SoftPro® AIO Iron Master Katalox Water Filter stands out as a robust solution for homeowners battling iron, manganese, and sulfur issues in their water supply, especially in well water systems. The installation process is user-friendly, and the maintenance requirements are minimal, making it a convenient choice for most households. While the shipping process and installation instructions might need improvement, the overall performance and customer satisfaction levels are notably high. If you’re seeking an efficient, reliable, and user-friendly water treatment system to tackle a range of issues including iron, this system is certainly worth considering.
2
Best pick for Iron up to 10 PPM
DROP Single Tank Aeration Filter
Pros
Cons
The DROP Single Tank Aeration Filter transcends typical water filtration, offering a holistic water management system. It employs advanced aeration to combat iron and sulfur, enhancing water purity. Integrated with the DROP ecosystem, including the DROP Hub and App, it ensures superior water quality, leak prevention, and water conservation. This eco-friendly solution offers customizable control and intelligent monitoring, making it an ideal choice for a smarter, more sustainable home, despite the initial learning curve and reliance on the DROP Hub.
3
Best pick for Iron between 4 and 7 PPM
SpringWell WS1 Whole House Well Water Filter System
The SpringWell WS1 is almost as a good as the SoftPro® AIO and will deal with most forms of water well iron contamination issues.
So if your not dealing with severe iron contamination, this is a comprehensive solution for homeowners with private wells contending with iron, manganese, sulfur, or a combination of these contaminants.
Made in the U.S.A., this system offers innovative water filtration technologies, ensuring clean, non-staining, and great-tasting water with zero drop in water pressure.
It comes with a lifetime warranty on tanks and valves and a satisfaction guarantee with a 6-month risk-free trial.
Pros
Cons
The SpringWell Whole House Well Water Filter System stands out as a robust and comprehensive solution for well water filtration. It effectively tackles common contaminants like iron, manganese, and sulfur, ensuring clean, non-staining, and great-tasting water.
The system’s maintenance-free operation, combined with innovative control and monitoring features, offers a user-friendly experience.
The investment in this system is justified by the significant improvements in water quality, the peace of mind provided by the lifetime warranty and satisfaction guarantee, and the assurance of using a product made in the U.S.A. with certified components.
Products are designed, assembled, and packaged in the USA at their Central Florida Facility, ensuring close oversight and high-quality standards.
For homeowners seeking a reliable, efficient, and advanced water filtration system for their well, the SpringWell system proves to be a top contender.
4
Best pick for Iron up to 3 PPM
Home Master (HMF3SdgFeC) 3-Stage Whole House Water Filter Review
Pros
Cons
At the time of writing this review there were 13 reviews, all largely positive which can be accessed by going to the Home Master Filter Product Page and clicking on the product review button located just above the product price. I’ve provided a snapshot below
The Home Master stands as a superior solution for those needing comprehensive water filtration in their homes. Its 3-stage system ensures the removal of a wide range of contaminants, providing clean and safe water for all household uses. The system’s design focuses on maintaining strong water pressure and reducing maintenance frequency, offering convenience and efficiency. Despite the potential challenges in installation due to its size and complexity, the system’s high performance, long filter life, and warranty make it an excellent investment for a home seeking a substantial upgrade in water quality.
5
Best Pick for High Flow Rates and Commercial Use
Crystal Quest Metal Removal Water Filtration System
Pros
Cons
For optimal removal of iron from well water, install an iron filter first to catch oxidized iron, followed by a water softener for minerals, ensuring the best iron filter for well water performance.
No special salt is needed; iron filters typically use an oxidizing media, not salt, for iron removal for well water.
Draining water softener brine into a sump pump isn't recommended due to potential corrosion, affecting even the best water softener for well water with iron.
UV light doesn't remove dissolved solids like iron; it's meant for sterilizing, not as a rust filter for well water.
The most cost-effective method can be using sediment filters or aeration, avoiding chemicals in iron removal for well water.
Combining well water iron filter systems with water softeners is effective, especially if the water softener for iron also contains a filtration stage.
Iron filters can last up to 20 years with proper maintenance, essential for the best well water iron filter system's longevity.
Regenerate every three days to maintain efficiency, crucial for any iron filter well water system.
While water softeners primarily target hardness, they can also remove small amounts of dissolved metals like iron, enhancing minerals in well water quality.
An iron water test identifies iron levels to ensure your filtering iron from water effectively and to adjust your well water iron removal system accordingly.
Sediment filters can remove particulate iron but not dissolved forms, necessitating a proper well water iron filtration system for complete treatment.
For well water rust removal, use iron-specific filters to oxidize and trap rust, supported by regular water tests for iron.
Ferrous iron is water-soluble and invisible, requiring an iron and water softener system for complete removal, while ferric iron, insoluble, needs an iron filter for water.
Water iron level charts can guide the setting of your iron water softener, ensuring efficient iron and manganese in water removal.
The best water filter for well water with iron combines both softening and filtering stages, as seen in iron water filtration systems for well water.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). (n.d.). Drinking Water Requirements for States and Public Water Systems: Iron in Drinking Water. Available at: https://www.epa.gov/dwreginfo/iron-drinking-water (Accessed: 24 January 2024).
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). (n.d.). Water-related Diseases and Contaminants in Public Water Systems: Iron. Available at: https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/drinking/public/water_diseases.html (Accessed: 8 January 2024).
National Ground Water Association (NGWA). (n.d.). Private Well Owner Information: Iron in Well Water. Available at: https://www.ngwa.org/what-is-groundwater/Private-Well-Owner-Information (Accessed: 16 January 2024).
United States Geological Survey (USGS). (n.d.). Iron and Manganese in Groundwater. Available at: https://www.usgs.gov/special-topics/water-science-school/science/iron-and-manganese-groundwater (Accessed: 30 January 2024).
Mark Alpers, a seasoned entrepreneur in the U.S., spearheads an innovative initiative focused on revolutionizing Los Angeles' wastewater infrastructure and advocating for environmental protection. His journey, rooted in a profound interest in water systems and a commitment to unbiased information, has led to the developing of a respected platform providing clear insights into water treatment solutions. Mark's expertise encompasses the intricacies of water purification and extends to sustainable practices in water management. His work reflects a dedication to enhancing understanding and implementing effective, environmentally responsible water strategies.
Lasewers.org is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. Lasewers.org also participates in various affiliate programs such as CJ, Impact, ShareASale, and other sites, where we earn from qualifying purchases.
